Eight questions to ask before choosing a Shopify agency, the red flags to watch for, and a short checklist.
When you decide to build a Shopify store or move from another platform, dozens of agencies show up. They all say "fast, affordable, experienced". So how do you tell the real ones apart? This article covers the eight questions to ask before you sign a proposal, and the red flags to watch for.
1. Can they show live work?
A screenshot in a pitch deck is not enough. Open the stores the agency has built: try the speed on a phone, the product page and the checkout step. If possible, ask to speak briefly with one of those brands. An agency that avoids giving references is sending a signal.
2. Are the scope and the proposal clear?
A good proposal is written item by item: which pages, which integrations, how many revisions, and when it will be delivered. Vague "all-inclusive" proposals turn into extra costs later. Ask in writing what is out of scope too.
3. Whose account will the store be under?
The Shopify store, the domain and related accounts should be in your name. The agency can be added as an admin, but ownership stays with you. That way, even if you part ways with the agency, you do not lose access to your store.
4. Is responsibility in one pair of hands?
When design is in one place, integration in another and maintenance in a third, nobody takes responsibility when something breaks. Having one team manage design, development and integration makes the process far more predictable.
5. Does the agency choose the platform for you or for itself?
The right agency does not sell the same solution to every brand. Sometimes the answer is Shopify, sometimes custom software, sometimes just integrating your existing system properly. An agency that can say "you do not need this" in a discovery call is usually trustworthy.
6. How will success be measured?
Goals such as page speed, conversion rate and order processing time should be set at the start of the project and reported after delivery. "We will build a nice site" is not a goal.
7. What happens after launch?
E-commerce does not end at go-live. Ask what the support model looks like for maintenance, bug fixes, campaign-season preparation and development. Find out who you can reach, and how fast, during busy periods.
8. How will communication and the schedule work?
Weekly demos, a single point of contact and a written schedule are good signs. The best way to avoid surprises mid-project is to see progress from start to finish.
Red flags
- Guarantees such as "we will get you to the top of Google"
- Prices far below the market and an undisclosed scope
- Not showing references and live examples
- Wanting to open the store account in their own name
- Not mentioning testing or post-launch support
Is being a Shopify Partner enough?
Being a Shopify Partner shows that an agency has an official relationship with the platform, but it is not a quality guarantee on its own. The real measures are live work, references and clear answers to the questions above.
Short checklist
- I looked at live references and spoke with at least one.
- Scope, schedule and exclusions are written in the proposal.
- The store and domain will be opened in my name.
- Success metrics and the reporting routine are defined.
- The post-launch support model is in writing.
Ask us the same questions
At Commerslab we are ready to answer all of these openly. You can look at our Shopify Store Setup page for services, or get in touch directly.